Jesus & the Gospels

questions: 154
books cited: 28

Questions arising within and between the Gospels — the events of Jesus’ life, words, and the accounts that record them.

Showing 73–96 of 154

These marks echo where critical scholarship tends to land on each question — not GEBible’s own ruling.

Seen as a contradiction
Genuinely disputed
Seen as reconciled

Scholarly consensus: Leans toward reconciliation
Was Jesus taken to Caiaphas or Annas first?

The tension: Matthew 26:57 names Caiaphas explicitly as the high priest Jesus was led to.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward reconciliation
Did Jesus say, "Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up"?

The tension: John 2:19-21 has Jesus straightforwardly speak this saying as a public pronouncement at the temple cleansing, and the narrator helpfully tells us he meant the…

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward a genuine contradiction
How did Jesus respond when questioned by the high priest?

The tension: Matthew 26:64 and Luke 22:70 give Jesus the famously evasive 'thou hast said' / 'ye say that I am' — an answer that can be parsed as a yes, a no, or a 'that's…

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Widely regarded as a genuine contradiction
To whom did Peter deny knowing Jesus?

The tension: All four gospels agree Peter denied Jesus three times, but they disagree on the cast list.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Widely regarded as a genuine contradiction
How did Judas die?

The tension: Matthew 27:5 has Judas return the silver, throw it down in the temple, and go hang himself — a tidy suicide-by-hanging.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Widely regarded as a genuine contradiction
Who bought the potter's field?

The tension: Matthew 27:6-7 has the chief priests buy the potter's field with the silver Judas threw back at them, because as blood money it can't go in the temple treasury.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward a genuine contradiction
Was Jesus silent during his trial before Pilate?

The tension: Matthew 27:12-14 and Mark 15:3-5 have Jesus go silent in front of Pilate — refusing to answer the chief priests, refusing to answer a word, until Pilate himsel…

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward reconciliation
Who put the robe on Jesus?

The tension: Luke 23:11 has Herod Antipas and his soldiers dress Jesus in a gorgeous robe during the side-trip to Herod's quarters that only Luke records, before sending hi…

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward reconciliation
What color was Jesus' robe?

The tension: Matthew 27:28 says the soldiers put a *scarlet* robe (*chlamyda kokkinēn*) on Jesus.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward a genuine contradiction
Who carried Jesus' cross?

The tension: John 19:17 has Jesus carry his own cross to Golgotha — explicitly, *bastazōn heautō ton stauron*.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Genuinely disputed among scholars
What did the soldiers give Jesus to drink?

The tension: Matthew 27:34 says they offered Jesus vinegar mingled with gall.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward reconciliation
What did the sign over Jesus' head say?

The tension: All four gospels report the *titulus* nailed to Jesus' cross — but they don't agree on the wording.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward a genuine contradiction
Did both thieves revile Jesus?

The tension: Mark 15:32 says both of those crucified with Jesus reviled him.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Widely regarded as a genuine contradiction
When was Jesus Crucified?

The tension: Mark 15:25 puts the crucifixion explicitly at the third hour — about 9 a.m.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Widely regarded as a genuine contradiction
What were the last words of Jesus?

The tension: Matthew 27:46-50 (following Mark 15:34-37) has Jesus die crying out the cry of dereliction — *Eli Eli lama sabachthani*, 'my God my God why hast thou forsaken…

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward a genuine contradiction
What did the Centurion call Jesus when he died?

The tension: Mark 15:39 and Matthew 27:54 both have the centurion at the cross declare 'Truly this was the Son of God.' Luke 23:47 has the centurion glorify God and say 'Ce…

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward a genuine contradiction
Where did the women watching the crucifixion stand?

The tension: Matthew 27:55, Mark 15:40, and Luke 23:49 all describe the women watching the crucifixion *from afar* (*apo makrothen* in the Greek).

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward a genuine contradiction
Who buried Jesus?

The tension: Matthew, Mark, and Luke all give Joseph of Arimathea sole credit for taking Jesus down, wrapping the body in linen, and laying it in the tomb.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward reconciliation
When did the women (or woman) arrive at the sepulchre?

The tension: John 20:1 has Mary Magdalene arrive at the tomb 'early, when it was yet dark' — before sunrise.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward a genuine contradiction
Who did the women see at the tomb?

The tension: Matthew 28:2 has an angel of the Lord descend from heaven, roll back the stone, and sit on it — a single angelic figure.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Leans toward a genuine contradiction
When did the women discover that Jesus's body was missing?

The tension: Luke 24:2-4 and John 20:1-2 have the women (or Mary Magdalene) discover the body is missing *before* they encounter any angelic figure — they enter, find the b…

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Widely regarded as a genuine contradiction
Did the women immediately tell the disciples?

The tension: Matthew 28:8 has the women run from the tomb 'with fear and great joy' to bring the disciples word.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Widely regarded as a genuine contradiction
Did Mary Magdalene recognize Jesus when he first appeared to her?

The tension: Matthew 28:9 has Mary and the other Mary meet the risen Jesus, grab his feet, and worship him — no confusion, instant recognition.

View the question
Scholarly consensus: Widely regarded as a genuine contradiction
Where did Jesus tell his disciples to go after his resurrection?

The tension: Matthew 28:10 and Mark 16:7 have Jesus (or his angelic messenger) tell the disciples to head north to Galilee — that's where they'll see him.

View the question